Welcome to your Kitzur Quiz - Siman 137
7.
It was the first day of Sukkos. Shmuel was still fast asleep when his good neighbor, Shaul, knocked on his house door to ask to borrow his 4 species. His gracious wife kindly gave them to Shaul on condition that he gift them back when he's done using them. Shmuel did not know this transaction occurred but would have happily have given the 4 species to his friend as well. (1) Did Shaul fulfill his obligation? (2)Can Shmuel fulfill his obligation with these 4 species?